| |
Pros |
Cons |
Characteristics |
Filter Specific Notes |
Fiberglass Panel Filters
 |
- Inexpensive
- Low
air flow restriction
- Full
depth loading
- Panel
filter
- Available
at most hardware stores
|
- Not
efficient
- Allow
most dust to pass through
|
- Disposable
- 1
and 2 inch thickness
- Panel
filters
|
- Fiberglass
panel filters are the worst
possible air filter you could use in your heating or air
conditioning system and I would never recommend using them
|
Media Air Filter Pads
  |
- Low
air flow restriction
- Don’t
have to be changed as often as pleated filters
- Great
for those who sometimes forget to change or clean their filters
- Not
face loading (increases dust loading capacity)
|
- Can
be messy to change because they have to be removed from a frame which
can release dust back into the air
- Not
as efficient as high end pleated air filters
|
- Disposable
- 1/2,
1 and 2 inch thickness
- Available
in pre-cut
pads or rolls that
can be cut to size
- Require
metal filter frame to mount them in
|
- Very
high dust loading capacity (full depth of media) because of
multi-denier design characteristics
- Good
for those who require more flexibility with filter change schedules
- Carbon
filter pads can be installed with these media pads for odor control
- Permanent
frame with disposable pads
- Usually
made with polyester fibers bonded together
- Often
available with dry tack or other coating to increase efficiency
- Some
designs make their filter media more course on the air leaving side to
improve filter performance
|
Electrostatic Air Filters
True
electrostatic filters don’t require electricity.
  
|
- Permanent
and washable
- Moderate
air flow restriction
- Most
last for years
- Many
have lifetime warranties
- No
face loading (increases dust loading capacity)
- No
electricity required
- No
ozone is produced with these filters
- One
time purchase cost – saves you money
|
- Many
different designs and not all are good quality
- If
not properly maintained they will restrict air flow
- Regular
cleaning is required
|
- Don’t
require electricity
- Washable
- Should
be cleaned monthly
- 1/2
and 1 inch thick
- Custom
sizes often available
- aluminum
or flex frames available
- Panel
design
|
- Maintenance
is very important with these filters
- Green?
They don’t add to landfill usage compared to disposables because they
last many years
- Some
brands use anti microbial protection which inhibits the growth of mold
and mildew on the filter material
- Direct
replacement for disposable panel filters
- Combines
3 to 5 layers of material to obtain desired characteristics
- Electrostatic air filters don’t produce ozone
|
Pleated Air Filters
 |
- Available
in wide range of MERV ratings from 5 to 12
- Low
to moderate air flow restriction
- Panel
filter
- Can
be found at most hardware stores
|
- If
not changed when needed they will impact air flow
- Face
loading (pleated design helps increase dust loading capacity)
|
- Disposable
- Available
in 1 to 6 inches thick
- Available
in custom sizes
- Panel
filter
- The
more efficientpleated air filters are great for allergy
sufferers
|
- Most
common type of furnace filter and
air conditioner filter available
- Some
brands are enhanced with electrostatic characteristics
- Variety
of media types - cotton, synthetic blends and polyester
- Some
are made with carbon (charcoal) impinged material to help control odor
- Many
manufacturers such as Trion, Honeywell, Nordic Filtrete, Air Bear and
many others
- Made
with pleated design to increase surface area and dust loading capacity,
this increases usable life
|
Hepa Air Filters
What
does HEPA stand for?
High Efficiency Particulate Arrestance
|
- Panel
filter
- Very
efficient filters
- One
of the most efficient filters available for residential use
|
- Can
have a negative impact on air flow, especially if not maintained
properly
- Face
loading (pleated design helps increase dust loading capacity)
|
- 1,
2 and 4 inch thickness
- Pleated
design
- Good
choice for those who have allergies
|
- Hepa
filters are often
available in bypass systems
- Similar
design as standard pleated filters but more pleats per inch and
different filter material
- Some
can be cleaned and reused several times
- These
filters are commonly used in vacuum cleaners, air exchangers (HRV) and
air purifiers
|
Electronic Air Cleaners
I
consider any type of air filter that uses electricity to be an
electronic air filter.
|
- Very
efficient but not with larger dust particles
- Virtually
no restriction to air flow
- Excellent
for use in combination with panel and other media air filters
- Lasts
for many years
|
- Requires
120 or 240 volt power supply
- Larger
dust particles pass through this air cleaner
- Duct
system must be modified to install this equipment (not difficult for
handyman)
- Expensive
initial investment compared to media type air filters
- Can
create ozone
|
- Charges
dust particles as they pass through and they are attracted to
collection plates
|
- Requires
regular maintenance to maintain efficient operation
- There
are two different designs of electronic air filters to choose from 1)
Uses electronic cells with collection plates and 2) Panel type
electronic filters that incorporate filter media in the design
|
| UV Air Cleaners |
- No
restriction to air flow
- Excellent
for use in combination with media air filters such as pleated and
electrostatic
- Can
be easily installed by a handyman
- Easy
maintenance – change lamp once per year
|
- Requires
electricity to operate
- Create
ozone – some are worse than others
|
- Kills
mold spores, viruses, bacteria, and many allergens
|
- Some
lamps produce UV-V light while others produce UV-C light
- The
UV-V type ultraviolet lamp produces more ozone
- Avoid
looking directly at the light because it could damage your eyes
- Damages
plastic drain pans and rubber components so must be installed properly
|